Green Living with Multiple Pets

Miles Dalton

No Comments

Composting Dog Poop vs Using Digester Enzymes

Composting Dog Poop vs. Using Digester Enzymes

Proper disposal of dog poop is something every responsible pet owner has to think through carefully. Both composting dog poop and using digester enzymes offer eco-friendly options, but what makes one better than the other? Let’s compare these two methods to help you make an informed decision.

What is Composting Dog Poop?

Composting is the process of breaking down organic material into usable soil through natural decomposition. Similar to composting kitchen scraps or yard clippings, dog poop can also be composted.

Benefits of Composting Dog Poop

  • Environmental Impact: Composting reduces waste in landfills and diminishes methane emissions, a potent greenhouse gas.
  • Soil Enrichment: The end product of composting, called compost, enriches soil by adding nutrients and improving soil structure.
  • Resource Efficiency: It makes productive use of what would otherwise be waste.
  • Cost-Effective: It can save you from purchasing compost for gardening purposes.

Challenges of Composting Dog Poop

  • Pathogens: Dog feces can contain harmful bacteria and parasites such as E. coli and roundworms. Special care is essential to kill these pathogens during the composting process.
  • Dedicated Compost Bin: A compost bin dedicated to dog poop is advisable to avoid contaminating regular compost.
  • Time-Consuming: The composting process can take several months before the feces break down adequately.
  • High Temperature: Effective composting requires maintaining high temperatures to ensure complete pathogen destruction.

How to Compost Dog Poop Safely

1. **Choose a Dedicated Compost Bin:** Purchase or build a compost bin specifically for dog waste. This bin should ideally be placed away from your main garden to avoid cross-contamination.

2. **Use Carbon-Rich Materials:** Add materials such as leaves, newspapers, and sawdust to balance the high nitrogen content of the poop. This balance helps speed up the composting process.

3. **Ensure Adequate Heat:** Maintain the pile at temperatures above 140°F (60°C) for several days to destroy harmful pathogens. A compost thermometer can help you monitor the temperature accurately.

4. **Turn the Pile Regularly:** Turning the compost pile helps aerate it and promotes even decomposition. Make sure you wear gloves while handling the pile.

5. **Check for Maturity:** The compost is ready to use once it has a dark, crumbly texture and an earthy odor. Always let it age for at least six months before using it on non-edible plants.

What are Digester Enzymes?

Digester enzymes offer an alternative solution to handle dog poop. Enzymes are biological molecules that help speed up chemical reactions, in this case, breaking down organic matter more quickly.

Benefits of Digester Enzymes

  • Convenience: Enzyme-based systems are easy to use and require minimal maintenance.
  • Quick Breakdown: Enzymes speed up the decomposition process, reducing waste volume rapidly.
  • Eco-Friendly: They provide an eco-friendly disposal method, mitigating the environmental impact of dog waste.
  • Odor Reduction: Many enzyme solutions help neutralize unpleasant odors.

Challenges of Using Digester Enzymes

  • Initial Cost: Installing a digester system requires an investment, though it can be cost-effective long-term.
  • Location Restrictions: Some systems need specific environmental conditions to work effectively. For example, the inground systems might not work in areas with a high water table or extremely cold climates.
  • Replenishment:**\:** Enzyme solutions typically need periodic replenishment to maintain effectiveness, adding to the recurring cost.

How to Use Digester Enzymes Effectively

1. **Choose the Right System:** There are several types of digester enzyme systems available, including underground digesters and septic tank additives. Choose the one that best suits your living conditions and needs.

2. **Install Properly:** Follow the manufacturer’s instructions to install the system correctly. This often involves digging a hole to place an underground container for the enzyme solution.

3. **Add Poop and Enzymes:** Regularly add dog poop to the system, along with the recommended amount of enzyme solution. Most systems have guidelines on how much enzyme to add based on the amount of waste.

4. **Monitor and Maintain:** Regularly check the system to ensure it is functioning well. Add more enzymes as needed and ensure the system is not overloaded.

Comparing Composting and Digester Enzymes

Now that we’ve looked at the benefits and challenges of both methods, how do they stack up against each other?

Environmental Impact

Both composting dog poop and using digester enzymes offer sustainable ways to dispose of dog feces. Composting creates nutrient-rich compost that can be used to enrich soil, while enzyme solutions decompose poop quickly and reduce its environmental footprint.


When it comes to convenience, digester enzymes usually take center stage. They require less monitoring and maintenance compared to composting, which involves careful temperature control and regular pile turning. If your schedule is tight, digester enzymes might be a better fit.


Composting dog poop can be very cost-effective as it mostly involves setting up a compost bin and managing household waste items, such as leaves and newspapers. Digester enzyme systems, though requiring an initial investment, can save time and labor, balancing out the costs over time.


Safety is a crucial consideration. Composting requires a high level of attention to temperature and practices to ensure all pathogens are destroyed. Enzyme solutions generally offer a safer alternative because the enzymes break down harmful substances more efficiently.

End Uses

The compost produced from dog poop can be used to enrich plant soil, though it’s recommended to use it for ornamental plants rather than edible ones due to potential pathogen risks. Digester enzyme systems, on the other hand, treat the waste without leaving a usable by-product.

Should You Compost Dog Poop or Use Digester Enzymes?

The decision between composting dog poop and using digester enzymes is influenced by various factors, including your time availability, budget, and the specific needs of your household. Here are some questions that might help guide you:

  • Do you have a garden or plan to use compost? If you enjoy gardening and could use extra compost, then composting dog poop may be particularly beneficial.
  • Do you have limited time or desire for maintenance? If you prefer something more hands-off, digester enzymes might be the more convenient option.
  • Is your residence compatible with these methods? Consider if your living environment can support a compost bin or an inground digester. Certain conditions like space and weather will be important in determining feasibility.
  • Do you have other pets or children? Safety should be a high priority, especially if you have other pets or children who might come into contact with decomposing waste.

Finishing Thoughts

Managing dog poop is more than just a necessity; it offers an opportunity to make more environmentally conscious choices that benefit not just you but the community as a whole. Whether you choose to compost dog poop or use digester enzymes, each method provides unique advantages and challenges. Understanding these can help you select a method that aligns best with your needs and lifestyle. Your commitment to responsible pet ownership truly makes a difference, one small act at a time.

Photo of author


Miles Dalton

Leave a Comment